California Lemon Law: When the Dealer Cannot Duplicate the Problem

By Raymond A. Velarde | Lemon Law Man APC
A repair order that says “could not duplicate” does not automatically defeat a California lemon law claim. A visit can count as a repair opportunity even if the dealer performs no repair work. You still need evidence of a covered defect and a reasonable opportunity for the manufacturer to fix it.
If your car loses power, shifts unpredictably, or repeatedly displays a warning that disappears at the dealership, the repair history deserves a closer look.
Does a visit count if the dealer does not fix anything
It can. California’s jury instruction on repair opportunities, CACI No. 3202, explains that presenting a vehicle to the manufacturer or its authorized repair facility for repair counts as an opportunity even when no repair work is performed.
The circumstances of each visit matter. A completed service visit for an unresolved problem is different from an appointment you scheduled but never attended. Keep records showing what you reported and what opportunity the dealership had to investigate.
What else must be shown
For a manufacturer buyback or replacement claim involving a qualifying new vehicle, including a qualifying lease, the defect must be covered by the warranty and substantially impair the vehicle’s use, value, or safety. The manufacturer or its authorized repair facility must have failed to correct it after a reasonable number of opportunities.
You generally do not have to identify the precise mechanical cause yourself. But a repair order alone does not prove every part of a claim.
There is no universal four-visit requirement. California has a separate lemon law presumption with specific conditions during the first 18 months or 18,000 miles, whichever comes first. You can have a valid claim without meeting that presumption.
Bought used or certified pre-owned? Eligibility requires a separate review. Remaining factory coverage or a CPO label does not automatically establish a right to a manufacturer buyback.
Five steps to protect your repair history
1. Describe the symptom precisely. Explain what happens, how often, and under what conditions. Report what you actually experience rather than guessing which part failed.
2. Check the repair order. Ask the service adviser to include every concern. If something is missing or inaccurate, request a correction in writing and keep your original copy.
3. Keep a simple incident log. Record dates, mileage, symptoms, repair visits, and days without the vehicle. Keep existing photos or videos, but never recreate a dangerous condition or film while driving.
4. Save every repair document. Keep records even when the diagnosis is “no fault found.” Save relevant dealer messages, manufacturer case numbers, and towing or rental receipts too.
5. Report recurring problems promptly. Tell the authorized dealer when the same issue returns and provide a reasonable opportunity for repair. If the vehicle may be unsafe, request guidance about towing rather than driving it to prove the problem.
Get advice before accepting an offer
A qualifying claim may support a buyback or replacement and recoverable incidental expenses. A buyback may include a lawful deduction for use; it is not automatically a refund of every dollar spent.
Timing matters. For manufacturers covered by California’s newer procedures, written notice and waiting periods can affect civil penalties. See our guide to AB 1755 and Section 871. Have an attorney check the applicable requirements and deadlines before filing.
California law allows a prevailing buyer to recover reasonable attorney fees and costs. Your written fee agreement explains your arrangement with the firm.
Talk with a Los Angeles lemon law attorney
Lemon Law Man APC represents consumers in Los Angeles and throughout California. Before representing consumers, attorney Raymond Velarde handled lemon law cases for auto manufacturers.
If the dealership keeps returning your vehicle without resolving the problem, we can review your repair history and explain your options. Call or text 626-671-5699 for a free case evaluation.
Request your free case evaluation | Have your purchase or lease agreement and repair orders available.
General information only, not legal advice. Reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship. Results depend on the facts.
Legal sources: CACI 3201 · CACI 3202 · CACI 3203 · Civil Code 1793.2 · Civil Code 1794 · Rodriguez v. FCA · CCP 871.24

Comments